January 15, 2025

Emmanuel "Manny" F. Piñol

Official Website

Confronting the Cartels SOLVING THE STINKING ISSUE OF GARLIC, ONION CARTELS By Manny Piñol

There are cartels manipulating the prices of at least four basic commodities whose level of production is not enough to supply the requirements of the country.
These four commodities are rice, meat, garlic and onion and milk and dairy products.
Organised groups of businessmen have been able to manipulate the supply in the market and the prices simply because the Agriculture Department has failed to focus on efforts to increase the production level of these food items.
In spite of hundreds of millions spent for the Philippine Dairy Program, for example, the country’s dairy farmers could only produce 1% of the national requirements.
The country’s cattle population has remained at 2.5-million heads despite the decades-old Animal Dispersal Program and billions splurged in the procurement of overpriced cattle making the country dependent on imported meat.
Rice is another commodity which is vulnerable to price manipulation by cartels, especially so since the country needs to import about 800,000 metric tons every year to fill up the national consumption.
The most serious problem of supply and price manipulation is in the garlic and onion sectors.
This is mainly because of the dependence of the country for imported garlic and onion which I really believe is a situation which was allowed to prevail by previous officials of the Agriculture Department for the most despicable reason, greed.
For the life of me, I cannot still understand why the Department has failed to come up with a rational and sustainable program to develop the garlic and onion industries even when Filipino farmers have shown that they could actually grow these products.
The Philippines imports 93% of its garlic requirements and about 70% of its onion requirements.
Interventions to improve the production of these commodities have been largely token, with the Department only giving out seeds and constructing a few cold storage facilities.
How do the cartels control the garlic and onion industries?
Masquerading as farmers’ co-operatives and colluding with corrupt officials of the Department in the past, the cartels, composed mainly of Divisoria and Binondo based groups, have cornered the importation permits issued by the Bureau of Plant Industry in the past.
Since these groups have the money to finance their operations, they monopolised the cold storage facilities so that local onion and garlic farmers could not produce large volumes.
There are even accounts saying that government-established cold storage facilities are leased by the cartels on yearly basis just to deprive local farmers of storage facilities thus forcing them to sell locally produced garlic and onion at very low prices and discourage them from expanding the planted areas.
To manipulate the prices, the cartels control the volume of importation, especially during the off-harvest season of garlic and onion in China and India, the two main sources of the commodities.
For this year, for example, only 22,000-metric tons of the over 50,000 metric tons of Garlic required by the country were brought in by importers, in spite of the fact that they were issued SPS permits to cover the said volume.
The insufficient supply pushed up the prices of Garlic in the markets, prompting Senate Agriculture Committee Chair Cynthia Villar to initiate a Senate investigation.
I saw these problems when I assumed office but to expect the Agriculture Department leadership to right away eliminate the problem is to ignore the fact that age-old institutional problems require institutional solutions.
What was initially done was to link Onion and Garlic farmers with direct buyers like SM Supermarket, Robinson’s, Rustan’s, Puregold and other direct users through the Kapatid Go Negosyo program.
A loaning program is also being prepared now for Onion and Garlic farmers with a maximum loanable amount of P25,000 per hectare.
This loaning program will be started in Bongabon, Nueva Ecija where workers of the Agricultural Credit Policy Council (ACPC) and information technology experts of the Department are now accrediting farmers prior to the start of the loaning program.
Admittedly, the 2017 Budget of the Department did not carry sufficient funding for Garlic and Onion Development but it must be understood that the 2017 Budget was prepared by the previous administration.
In the 2018 Proposed Budget, a P200-M (instead of P50-M as earlier proposed) has been submitted to jump-start the 5-Year Road Map for Garlic and Onion Development.
This involves the support for traditional production areas of Onion and Garlic Production and the development of new production areas in other parts of the country.
This will include the introduction of modern technology in Garlic and Onion farming to allow farmers to plant more than once during the year.
All Garlic and Onion farmers will also be given access to the Production Loan Easy Access (PLEA) Program of ACPC which offers a maximum of P25,000 per farming household without any collateral and a 6% interest annually.
Additional cold storage facilities will also be established in the traditional production areas, including Nueva Ecija, Nueva Viscaya, Ilocos and Mindoro.
Pilot Garlic and Onion farms will be established in the Visayas and Mindanao.
By the end of the term of President Rody Duterte, the Agriculture Department aims to be able to 50% of the Garlic and 80% of the Onion requirements of the country.
When that is achieved, the Cartels will no longer be able to manipulate the supply and prices in the market.
(Photos downloaded from public websites)

You may have missed

21-Year-Old Cotabato Airport: Sad Story Of Childish Politics Twenty-one years after work on the Cotabato Rural Airport was started and 15 years after the Runway and Terminal Building construction were completed, it remains unused, a sad testament to the evils of petty and childish politics which had prevailed in North Cotabato. For people to truly understand this tragic narrative of a project which could have brought progress to the province, here is the historical account of the Mlang Airport Project: 1. I was a young Mayor of Mlang (1995-1998) when I envisioned the growth of my town into an agro-industrlialized city and thought an Airport would be critical in realizing that vision; 2. With the help of the Vice Mayor then, Luigi Buenaflor Cuerpo, whose family owned most of the areas in the former Hacienda de Tomas Buenaflor, I presented the idea to the elders of the clan and they loved the idea but since there were no funds available for the project, it remained just a dream; 3. In 1998, after one term as Mayor of Mlang, I was elected Governor of North Cotabato and I pursued the vision of building an airport in my hometown; 4. In 2003, the Sangguniang Panlalawigan authorized the purchase of 62 hectares of land in the former Hacienda Buenaflor for the purpose of building the airport; 5. With an initial P30-M Grant Fund which was provided by then Pres. Gloria Macapagal-Arroyo sourced from the Department of Energy (which at the time, operated the Mt. Apo Geothermal Project), the project was started in 2004; 6. By 2007, my term as Governor ended and I was succeeded by Governor Jesus N. Sacdalan. I served as his Vice Governor. Gov. Sacdalan continued the project; 7. In 2009, the Runway and Terminal Building of the Mlang Airport were completed and Pres. Gloria Macapagal Arroyo arrived for the blessing and inauguration; 8. In the 2010 elections, Gov. Sacdalan ran for Congress in the 1st District of the Province while I attempted to regain the Governorship but I lost to then Congresswoman Emmylou Taliño-Santos (now Mendoza); That was when work at the Airport was stopped and to justify the suspension of the Airport Development, the new administration claimed that the documents covering the purchase of the land were not perfect. I was accused of owning the land which was, of course, ridiculous and false. It was also claimed that the project was started without a Feasibility Study which again is a big lie, for how would it be given a budget if there was no study conducted. In fact, I made a public declaration that I was willing to help perfect the documents if they needed my signature on the alleged incomplete documents but my offer was ignored. In 2019, when former Congresswoman Nancy Catamco won as Governor, the alleged missing documents were recovered or reconstructed and perfected. That was when work was started again in the airport. Unfortunately, in 2022, Gov. Catamco lost in a tightly contested election to then Vice Governor Emmylou Taliño-Mendoza before she could turn over the Airport Land Property which is owned by the Provincial Government to the Dept. of Transportation and the Civil Aeronautics Authority of the Philippines for it to be operational. The incumbent Governor is the Chairman of the Regional Development Council and she could have given utmost priority to the completion of Airport. Access to funds for the completion of the project would not be difficult because Speaker Martin Romualdez is the nephew-in-law of her husband, TUCP Partylist Congressman Raymond Mendoza. The real reason why the Mlang Airport Development has dragged for 21 years is because it is identified as the Brainchild and Pet Project of former Governor Manny Piñol and the current leadership dread the thought of seeing planes loaded with passengers and fruits from Cotabato to the big cities and the people giving credit to Piñol for initiating the project. The airport is for the people of North Cotabato now and the next generation and I would not care if she names it after her grandfather or whoever. This narrative is my account of the real story behind the delay in the completion of the Central Mindanao Airport which I know will be refuted by the other party. So, here is my challenge: Let’s hold a Public Debate/Forum on the real and true reasons behind the delay in the completion of the Central Mindanao Airport. I am willing to face anybody from their side in that debate, anytime and anywhere. The People of North Cotabato deserve to know the truth. #WeDontOwnGovernment! #TheTruthWillSetUsFree!