January 16, 2025

Emmanuel "Manny" F. Piñol

Official Website

Well-funded black propaganda THE SECOND MASSACRE OF THE MANGUDADATUS

By Manny Piñol
People who know that Maguindanao Governor Esmael Mangudadatu and I are friends have called my attention to an article circulating in the social media attacking the Mangudadatu family for their ostentatious display of wealth and their recent trip to Las Vegas, Nevada to witness the Manny Pacquiao-Floyd Mayweather Fight of the Century.
Being a former politician and having experienced similar black propaganda operations in the past, I initially shrugged off the issue and dismissed it as “part of the game” until my US-based wedding godson, Jeff de Guzman, sent me the link to the article which appeared in a political website politics.com.ph.
Reading the article, I was aghast at the plain and simple lies peddled by the writer who introduced himself as Adeeb Limbutungan, obviously an alias, and who claimed to be part of an advocacy group protecting the interests of the people of Maguindanao.
What particularly angered me was the patent lie in the very first paragraph where he said that the Mangudadatus flew “en masse” to Las Vegas to watch the Pacquiao-Mayweather fight and spent hundreds of thousands of pesos on the boxing tickets and the plane tickets at the expense of the people of Maguindanao.
“Weeks after Maguindanao was placed under a state of calamity due to the recent joint military and police operation against the Bangsamoro Islamic Freedom Fighters (BIFF), one of our officials – Buluan, Maguindanao Vice Mayor King Jhazzer Mangudadatu and other members of the Mangudadatu clan flew en masse to Las Vegas to see the Fight of the Century. Their boxing and plane tickets worth hundreds of thousands of pesos could have already fed 80,000 evacuees in our place,” the article said.
“En masse?” Boxing tickets worth hundreds of thousands of pesos?
The author of the black prop should have double checked his facts and should have made sure that there were no direct witnesses who could testify that what is being peddled is a brazen lie.
Unfortunately for him and his group, I and my 12-year-old son, Bernhart Immanuel, were with Gov. Mangudadatu shortly before the fight and right after the fight.
Gov. Mangudadatu was with his wife and son, Vice Mayor King.
Now, here are the facts:
First, the boxing tickets worth $5,000 each was given FREE by Manny Pacquiao. Imman and I also got the same tickets and were seated behind the Mangudadatus.
Second, in the US, the Mangudadatus rode in an old Mitsubishi Montero worth $3,000 owned by Jeff de Guzman. Gov. Mangudadatu had to buy new tires to replace two worn out tires of the old SUV.
Third, they took a taxi cab from their hotel to join me and my son at the Palms Hotel on Sunday morning, May 3 to take a 4-hour trip to Coachella Valley in Southern California to visit the modern farms in the desert to see how the technology could be transferred to Maguindanao province.
I was with them. I drove the Montero from Las Vegas to Coachella Valley where i showed Gov. Toto and King Jhazzer modern farming technology in the desert.
The result of that trip is a program called “Peace Farmers Program” where 12 Muslim, Christian and Tiruray/Manobo agriculture students, three traditional farmers – Muslim, Christian and Tribal – and three college agri professors will be sent to coachella valley in a “learning by doing” OJT program to help improve Maguindanao agriculture.
The proposed program was submitted to the Sangguniang Panlalawigan of Maguindanao last Tuesday and copies of the “Peace Farmers Program” design was forwarded to the Office of the President and the US Ambassador to the Philippines Philip Goldberg.
After the trip to Coachella, Jeff drove Gov. Mangudadatu and his two companions back to Las Vegas from where they set off on the journey back home to the Philippines.
Now, hear this from a first hand witness: Gov. Mangudadatu did not gamble in the casino and he was not travelling “en masse” with other members of his family. How could the old Montero have accommodated more than six people which included me, my son, Imman, Jeff, and Gov. Toto and two others?
I am not defending Gov. Toto because he is my friend but as the former Governor of North Cotabato who saw first hand the kind of governance Maguindanao province had over the years, I can say with all certainty that Maguindanao has a better leader now in Gov. Mangudadatu.
He has the vision for the people and the province and I am honoured that he proudly tells people that most of the agriculture programs he is implementing now in Maguindanao were patterned from the very successful programs of North Cotabato when I was Governor.
The Plant Now Pay Later Program of North Cotabato which gave out planting materials of high value crops to farmers through a soft loan was copied by Gov. Mangudadatu with an improvisation: he gave out the seedlings for free knowing that his people are poor.
The Plow Now Pay Later Program which involved the use by the farmers of farm tractors payable after harvest was copied by Gov. Mangudadatu again with an improvisation: he will set up a complete farm equipment pool – tractors, planters, harvesters, bulldozers, backhoes, water drilling rig and others – which would be available to the farmers of Maguindanao.
The Study Now Pay Later Program of North Cotabato was improved by Maguindanao. Students are sent to college by the hundreds without having to pay the provincial government back.
Now, he is going to implement a provincial-funded technology transfer program through the “Peace Farmers Program” which will start August this year.
These are programs in Maguindanao unheard of in the previous years.
This was what I asked the author of the article against the Mangudadatus:
Did you raise this same issue and advocacy against the corruption in Maguindanao when Datu Andal Ampatuan flew to Las Vegas with a large entourage and placed hundreds of thousands of dollars of bets in Las Vegas casinos?
Did you question what business undertakings the Ampatuans were involved in to allow Datu Andal to shop in the boutiques of MGM grand and buy the most expensive Rolex watches in Beverly Hills where he paid in cash?
Did you raise a howl during the times when the Ampatuans passed through the national highways of North Cotabato in a convoy of 20 to 30 vehicles with fully armed bodyguards and terrorised other motorists?
Did you appeal for justice when the killings in Maguindanao were so brazen that even well-known people like Ed Mangansakan were murdered for simply crossing the path of this once very powerful political family.
Indeed, if the Mangudadatus have become wealthy, the question which should be raised is: Did they steal from government?
Have these people forgotten that long before the fishpens became popular, the Mangudadatus were already raking in money from their bangus fishpens in Lake Buluan, a body of water so rich with planktons that you do not have to feed the fish?
Have these people overlooked the fact that the Mangudadatu clan own vast tracts of ancestral land planted to Oil Palm and are now fully productive?
There may be some other things I am not privy to but then again the challenge is: If you can prove that the Mangudadatus stole money from government to finance their lifestyle, then file charges.
Becoming rich is neither a sin nor a crime. But stealing from the poor and killing innocent civilians are definitely evil deeds.
Reading the article between the lines, I can smell that there is a well-financed effort to demolish the Mangudadatus whose ascension to power in Maguindanao was a result of a painful episode in their lives – the still unsolved Ampatuan Massacre where Gov. Mangudadatu lost his wife, Gigi, King’s mother, his sisters and relatives and where over 30 media practitioners were also killed.
Instead of crying for justice for the victims of the Ampatuan Massacre, Adeeb Limbuntungan and his ilk are now hellbent on committing another massacre – the mass defamation of the Mangudadatus through baseless and blatant lies.
Some social media netizens may believe Limbuntungan’s lies but certainly not I, a direct witness, and many others who have followed the story of the province of Maguindanao all these years.
(Photo caption: Gov. Mangudadatu with US Tilapia farming pioneer Rocky French with the blue Montero in the background; Gov. Mangudadatu, French, his son, King, and my son, Imman, in the cornfields in the desert of Coachella. Photos by Manny Piñol)

You may have missed

21-Year-Old Cotabato Airport: Sad Story Of Childish Politics Twenty-one years after work on the Cotabato Rural Airport was started and 15 years after the Runway and Terminal Building construction were completed, it remains unused, a sad testament to the evils of petty and childish politics which had prevailed in North Cotabato. For people to truly understand this tragic narrative of a project which could have brought progress to the province, here is the historical account of the Mlang Airport Project: 1. I was a young Mayor of Mlang (1995-1998) when I envisioned the growth of my town into an agro-industrlialized city and thought an Airport would be critical in realizing that vision; 2. With the help of the Vice Mayor then, Luigi Buenaflor Cuerpo, whose family owned most of the areas in the former Hacienda de Tomas Buenaflor, I presented the idea to the elders of the clan and they loved the idea but since there were no funds available for the project, it remained just a dream; 3. In 1998, after one term as Mayor of Mlang, I was elected Governor of North Cotabato and I pursued the vision of building an airport in my hometown; 4. In 2003, the Sangguniang Panlalawigan authorized the purchase of 62 hectares of land in the former Hacienda Buenaflor for the purpose of building the airport; 5. With an initial P30-M Grant Fund which was provided by then Pres. Gloria Macapagal-Arroyo sourced from the Department of Energy (which at the time, operated the Mt. Apo Geothermal Project), the project was started in 2004; 6. By 2007, my term as Governor ended and I was succeeded by Governor Jesus N. Sacdalan. I served as his Vice Governor. Gov. Sacdalan continued the project; 7. In 2009, the Runway and Terminal Building of the Mlang Airport were completed and Pres. Gloria Macapagal Arroyo arrived for the blessing and inauguration; 8. In the 2010 elections, Gov. Sacdalan ran for Congress in the 1st District of the Province while I attempted to regain the Governorship but I lost to then Congresswoman Emmylou Taliño-Santos (now Mendoza); That was when work at the Airport was stopped and to justify the suspension of the Airport Development, the new administration claimed that the documents covering the purchase of the land were not perfect. I was accused of owning the land which was, of course, ridiculous and false. It was also claimed that the project was started without a Feasibility Study which again is a big lie, for how would it be given a budget if there was no study conducted. In fact, I made a public declaration that I was willing to help perfect the documents if they needed my signature on the alleged incomplete documents but my offer was ignored. In 2019, when former Congresswoman Nancy Catamco won as Governor, the alleged missing documents were recovered or reconstructed and perfected. That was when work was started again in the airport. Unfortunately, in 2022, Gov. Catamco lost in a tightly contested election to then Vice Governor Emmylou Taliño-Mendoza before she could turn over the Airport Land Property which is owned by the Provincial Government to the Dept. of Transportation and the Civil Aeronautics Authority of the Philippines for it to be operational. The incumbent Governor is the Chairman of the Regional Development Council and she could have given utmost priority to the completion of Airport. Access to funds for the completion of the project would not be difficult because Speaker Martin Romualdez is the nephew-in-law of her husband, TUCP Partylist Congressman Raymond Mendoza. The real reason why the Mlang Airport Development has dragged for 21 years is because it is identified as the Brainchild and Pet Project of former Governor Manny Piñol and the current leadership dread the thought of seeing planes loaded with passengers and fruits from Cotabato to the big cities and the people giving credit to Piñol for initiating the project. The airport is for the people of North Cotabato now and the next generation and I would not care if she names it after her grandfather or whoever. This narrative is my account of the real story behind the delay in the completion of the Central Mindanao Airport which I know will be refuted by the other party. So, here is my challenge: Let’s hold a Public Debate/Forum on the real and true reasons behind the delay in the completion of the Central Mindanao Airport. I am willing to face anybody from their side in that debate, anytime and anywhere. The People of North Cotabato deserve to know the truth. #WeDontOwnGovernment! #TheTruthWillSetUsFree!